"An Adult faith does not follow the waves of fashion and the latest novelties."
Pope Benedict XVI

Monday, September 29, 2008

VATICAN: Democratic Party = "Party Of Death"

(CNS) -- The Democratic Party in the United States "risks transforming itself definitively into a 'party of death,'" said U.S. Archbishop Raymond L. Burke, prefect of the Vatican's highest court.....

read full story here
THE CATHOLIC KNIGHT: In a stunning rebuke of the U.S. Democratic Party, a high ranking Vatican official (Archbishop Raymond Burke) has accused it of becoming a "party of death," leaving no doubt how some Vatican officials view this American institution. It's a serious blow with long lasting effects. The Prefect of the Apostolic Signature, which is comparable to the "chief justice" on the Vatican's "supreme court," (to use an American analogy), is the archbishop who overseas all matters relating to the ecclesiastical court system. His position in the worldwide Catholic Church is extremely significant and powerful, and makes him a serious future contender for the papal throne. Ergo, his condemnation of the U.S. Democratic Party is very damning. 

Rarely do Vatican officials take such strong stands of condemnation against political parties. This condemnation effectively puts the U.S. Democratic Party in a rare and distinguished "Hall of Shame," accompanied by such organizations as the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, and the Nazi Party of Hitler's Germany. In comparison to such extreme examples of political thuggery, it seems shocking that a high ranking Vatican official would characterize the U.S. Democratic Party this way. Why would he do this?

It's important to note that the good archbishop prefaced this characterization by stating that the Democratic Party "risks becoming" a party of death, and he did not say it had "already become" this. That's important, because the good archbishop is leaving room for a way out - an "exit strategy" if you will - for the Democratic Party to cease supporting the "culture of death" and mend it's wicked ways.

That being said, the reasons for his condemnation should be clear to anyone who knows the slightest bit about Church teaching on the sanctity of human life and traditional marriage.
  1. The Church teaches that abortion is a "grave sin" tantamount to murder and terrorism, while the Democratic Party asserts it is simply a matter of "personal choice."
  2. The Church teaches that euthanasia is also "murder" comparable to the eugenic programs of Nazi Germany, while the Democratic Party asserts it is simply "death with dignity."
  3. The Church teaches that embryonic stem-cell research is "baby farming," and "murder," similar to the kinds of human experiments performed by German doctors during the Third Reich, while the Democratic Party asserts it is simply "for a good cause."
  4. The Church teaches that gay-marriage is a "perversion of the natural law," and an "abomination before God," while the Democratic Party asserts it is simply a matter of "civil rights."
  5. The Church teaches that homosexual behavior is "perverse sin," and that young children should be sheltered from seeing it, while the Democratic Party asserts that it's "normal" and children should be taught to "embrace it" and be "tolerant" of it.
With such a dichotomy outlined like this, it becomes a bit more easy to understand why some Vatican officials might be inclined to think of the U.S. Democratic Party in such a negative light. Suspiciously absent is the voice of Pope Benedict XVI, which has been strangely silent, as high ranking Vatican officials make claims such as this. Those who are familiar with the nuances of "vatican-ese" (the diplomacy of Vatican words and actions) realize this could only mean one thing. The pope approves of the message. There are some things a pope simply cannot say in public. That should be well understood after the fallout following the pope's comments on Islam at the university in Germany a couple years back. Dozens of Christians lost their lives in Muslim riots after the pope quoted a medieval emperor simply in a rhetorical sense. A slip of a Vatican official's lips, exposing a message the pope does not endorse, is almost immediately followed by a disclaimer from the Vatican press office. Such is not the case following Archbishop Burke's comments harshly criticizing the U.S. Democratic Party. It simply leads one to believe the pope agrees.

"The Catholic Knight" also agrees, but as is typical of my character, I would like to take it a step further. In my opinion, the U.S. Democratic Party does not "risk" the possibility of becoming a "party of death," it instead already has, and there may be no turning back now.

3 comments:

Nancy said...

Not that this is new. Remember that in 1994 JPII and the Holy See went to battle against the Clinton government over the Cairo population conference and their attempt to use it to push for abortion as an international right (George Weigel had a good description in Witness to Hope of what went on). When Al Gore insisted that the US wasn't doing that, Navarro-Valls pointed out that including abortion in the documents was a US initiative, effectively calling Gore a liar. That JPII didn't contradict his spokesman spoke volumes.

Anonymous said...

Personally I care a lot more about what the rest of the world thinks about the U.S. and not just the Vatican. Not everyone in America is a staunch Catholic and there are much more important issues in the upcoming election than abortion and gay marriage. It's the extreme religious people in the country that ignore the real problems that affect the vast majority of people, like the economy, and instead focus on issues like gay marriage which doesn't really affect anyone. The times of scare tactics used to influence people's votes are over. America has awoken and I'm confident that as a whole the rational choice for this country to move forward will be made with the election of Senator Obama. If you want to talk about a party of death how about the Republican party under Bush that recklessly led us into the Iraq war under false pretenses without support from the rest of the world. It's irresponsible policies like that which shed a negative light on this great country of ours.

Bill said...

Personally I care a lot more about what the rest of the world thinks about the U.S. and not just the Vatican. Not everyone in America is a staunch Catholic and there are much more important issues in the upcoming election than abortion and gay marriage. It's the extreme religious people in the country that ignore the real problems that affect the vast majority of people, like the economy, and instead focus on issues like gay marriage which doesn't really affect anyone. The times of scare tactics used to influence people's votes are over. America has awoken and I'm confident that as a whole the rational choice for this country to move forward will be made with the election of Senator Obama. If you want to talk about a party of death how about the Republican party under Bush that recklessly led us into the Iraq war under false pretenses without support from the rest of the world. It's irresponsible policies like that which shed a negative light on this great country of ours.